In a finite-dimensional Hilbert space H of dimension n, consider a normalised vector ∣u⟩ and the operator
S^=1−2∣u⟩⟨u∣.
Question 1
Show that S^ is self-adjoint and that S^2=1. Deduce that S^ is unitary.
Solution
The projector ∣u⟩⟨u∣ is self-adjoint, so S^ is as well. Expanding and using ⟨u∣u⟩=1 gives
S^2=1−4∣u⟩⟨u∣+4∣u⟩⟨u∣u⟩⟨u∣=1−4∣u⟩⟨u∣+4∣u⟩⟨u∣=1.
Thus S^†S^=S^2=1:S^ is unitary. An operator that is both self-adjoint and unitary is its own inverse.
Question 2
Determine the eigenvalues and eigenspaces of S^. Calculate trS^ and detS^. Give the geometric interpretation of S^ in R3.
Solution
We have S^∣u⟩=∣u⟩−2∣u⟩=−∣u⟩:∣u⟩ is an eigenvector with eigenvalue −1. For every ∣v⟩ orthogonal to ∣u⟩,S^∣v⟩=∣v⟩: the hyperplane {∣u⟩}⊥, of dimension n−1, is the eigenspace associated with the eigenvalue +1. This confirms that the eigenvalues of an operator that is both unitary and self-adjoint, being real and of unit modulus, are ±1. It follows that trS^=(n−1)−1=n−2 and detS^=−1. We may also write S^=P^⊥−∣u⟩⟨u∣, where P^⊥=1−∣u⟩⟨u∣ is the projector onto the hyperplane. In R3,S^ leaves the vectors in the plane orthogonal to ∣u⟩ unchanged and reverses the sign of the component along ∣u⟩: it is the orthogonal reflection in this plane.
Question 3
In C2, calculate S^ for ∣u⟩=21(1,−1). Identify the result.
Solution
We have ∣u⟩⟨u∣=21(1−1−11), hence
S=(1001)−(1−1−11)=(0110)=σx.
The Pauli matrix σx is the reflection that leaves the vector 21(1,1) invariant and reverses the sign of 21(1,−1). For a photon, it may be interpreted as a plate that interchanges horizontal and vertical polarisations.
Question 4
In R3, let ∣x⟩=(3,4,0) and ∣y⟩=(5,0,0) have the same norm. Find a vector ∣u⟩ such that S^∣x⟩=∣y⟩, and verify the result.
Hint
A reflection that interchanges ∣x⟩ and ∣y⟩ must reverse the sign of ∣x⟩−∣y⟩.
Solution
The required reflection interchanges ∣x⟩ and ∣y⟩; it therefore reverses the sign of their difference and preserves their sum. Take ∣u⟩ collinear with ∣x⟩−∣y⟩=(−2,4,0), whose norm is 20:∣u⟩=201(−2,4,0). Then ⟨u∣x⟩=201(−6+16)=2010, and
S^∣x⟩=∣x⟩−2⟨u∣x⟩∣u⟩=(3,4,0)−2⋅2010(−2,4,0)=(3,4,0)−(−2,4,0)=(5,0,0)=∣y⟩.
This construction works whenever ∥x∥=∥y∥ and ⟨x∣y⟩ is real: one then checks that ∣x⟩+∣y⟩ is orthogonal to ∣x⟩−∣y⟩, and is therefore invariant under the reflection. It is widely used in numerical analysis to reduce a matrix to triangular form.