← Exercise library← All exercises for this theme
Theme 3 — Postulates and Applications

Angular momentum of a 2p orbital

Keywords: hydrogen atom · 2p orbital · spherical harmonics · angular momentum · measurement of Lz · normalisation

Exercise 1 : Angular momentum of a 2p orbital

Consider an electron in the hydrogen atom in the state

ψ(r)=N (x+y+2z) e−r/(2a),\psi(\mathbf r)=N\,(x+y+2z)\,e^{-r/(2a)},

where aa is the Bohr radius and N>0N>0 is a normalisation constant. Recall that the states ψnℓm=Rnℓ(r)Yℓm(θ,φ)\psi_{n\ell m}=R_{n\ell}(r)Y_{\ell m}(\theta,\varphi) are eigenstates of H^\hat H, L^2\hat L^2 and L^z\hat L_z with eigenvalues En=−13,6 eV/n2E_n=-13{,}6\ \mathrm{eV}/n^2, ℏ2ℓ(ℓ+1)\hbar^2\ell(\ell+1) and ℏm\hbar m, that R21(r)∝r e−r/(2a)R_{21}(r)\propto r\,e^{-r/(2a)}, and that

Y10=34πcos⁡θ,Y1,±1=∓38πsin⁡θ e±iφ.Y_{10}=\sqrt{\frac{3}{4\pi}}\cos\theta,\qquad Y_{1,\pm1}=\mp\sqrt{\frac{3}{8\pi}}\sin\theta\,e^{\pm i\varphi}.

Also take ∫0∞rqe−r/a dr=q! aq+1\int_0^\infty r^qe^{-r/a}\,dr=q!\,a^{q+1} and ∫cos⁡2θ dΩ=4π/3\int\cos^2\theta\,d\Omega=4\pi/3, where the integral is over all angles.

Question 1
Determine the normalisation constant NN.

Solution
In spherical coordinates, x+y+2z=r (sin⁡θcos⁡φ+sin⁡θsin⁡φ+2cos⁡θ)x+y+2z=r\,(\sin\theta\cos\varphi+\sin\theta\sin\varphi+2\cos\theta). Let us calculate the angular integral of its square. By symmetry, ∫(x/r)2dΩ=∫(y/r)2dΩ=∫(z/r)2dΩ=4π/3\int(x/r)^2d\Omega=\int(y/r)^2d\Omega=\int(z/r)^2d\Omega=4\pi/3, and cross terms such as ∫xy dΩ\int xy\,d\Omega vanish because they change sign under a symmetry that reverses the sign of only one coordinate. Thus

∫(x+y+2z)2 dΩ=r2(1+1+4)4π3=8πr2.\int(x+y+2z)^2\,d\Omega=r^2(1+1+4)\frac{4\pi}{3}=8\pi r^2 .

The normalisation condition is therefore

1=N2∫0∞8πr2 e−r/a r2dr=8πN2×4! a5=192πa5N2,N=1192π a5=183π a5/2.1=N^2\int_0^\infty8\pi r^2\,e^{-r/a}\,r^2dr=8\pi N^2\times4!\,a^5=192\pi a^5N^2, \qquad N=\frac{1}{\sqrt{192\pi\,a^5}}=\frac{1}{8\sqrt{3\pi}\,a^{5/2}}.

Question 2
Express xx, yy and zz in terms of rr and the spherical harmonics Y1mY_{1m}. Hence show that ψ\psi is a linear combination of the states ψ21m\psi_{21m}, giving their coefficients up to a common factor.

Hint
First express x+iyx+iy and x−iyx-iy in terms of Y1,1Y_{1,1} and Y1,−1Y_{1,-1}.

Solution
We have x±iy=rsin⁡θ e±iφ=∓r8π/3 Y1,±1x\pm iy=r\sin\theta\,e^{\pm i\varphi}=\mp r\sqrt{8\pi/3}\,Y_{1,\pm1} and z=rcos⁡θ=r4π/3 Y10z=r\cos\theta=r\sqrt{4\pi/3}\,Y_{10}. Let c=r4π/3c=r\sqrt{4\pi/3}, so that r8π/3=2 cr\sqrt{8\pi/3}=\sqrt2\,c. Taking the half-sum and half-difference gives

x=(x+iy)+(x−iy)2=c2(Y1,−1−Y11),y=(x+iy)−(x−iy)2i=ic2(Y11+Y1,−1),z=c Y10.x=\frac{(x+iy)+(x-iy)}{2}=\frac{c}{\sqrt2}\bigl(Y_{1,-1}-Y_{11}\bigr), y=\frac{(x+iy)-(x-iy)}{2i}=\frac{ic}{\sqrt2}\bigl(Y_{11}+Y_{1,-1}\bigr), \qquad z=c\,Y_{10}.

It follows that

x+y+2z=c[1+i2 Y1,−1+2 Y10+−1+i2 Y11].x+y+2z=c\left[\frac{1+i}{\sqrt2}\,Y_{1,-1}+2\,Y_{10}+\frac{-1+i}{\sqrt2}\,Y_{11}\right].

Since the radial factor r e−r/(2a)r\,e^{-r/(2a)} is proportional to R21R_{21}, the function ψ\psi is a combination of the three states ψ21m\psi_{21m}, with coefficients proportional to

1+i2 (m=−1),2 (m=0),−1+i2 (m=1).\frac{1+i}{\sqrt2}\ (m=-1),\qquad 2\ (m=0),\qquad \frac{-1+i}{\sqrt2}\ (m=1).

Question 3
What outcomes may be obtained from a measurement of the energy? Of L^2\hat L^2? With what probabilities?

Solution
The three states ψ21m\psi_{21m} have the same energy E2=−13,6/4≃−3,4E_2=-13{,}6/4\simeq-3{,}4 eV and the same value ℏ2ℓ(ℓ+1)=2ℏ2\hbar^2\ell(\ell+1)=2\hbar^2 of L^2\hat L^2. Any combination of these states is therefore still an eigenstate of H^\hat H and L^2\hat L^2: an energy measurement gives E2E_2 with certainty, and a measurement of L^2\hat L^2 gives 2ℏ22\hbar^2 with certainty.

Question 4
What are the possible outcomes of a measurement of L^z\hat L_z, and their probabilities? Calculate ⟨L^z⟩\langle\hat L_z\rangle.

Solution
The possible outcomes are −ℏ-\hbar, 00 and ℏ\hbar. Since the states ψ21m\psi_{21m} are orthonormal, the probabilities are proportional to the squared moduli of the coefficients found above:

∣1+i2∣2=1,∣2∣2=4,∣−1+i2∣2=1,\Bigl|\frac{1+i}{\sqrt2}\Bigr|^2=1,\qquad |2|^2=4,\qquad\Bigl|\frac{-1+i}{\sqrt2}\Bigr|^2=1,

whose sum is 66. Thus

P(Lz=−ℏ)=16,P(Lz=0)=23,P(Lz=ℏ)=16.P(L_z=-\hbar)=\frac16,\qquad P(L_z=0)=\frac23,\qquad P(L_z=\hbar)=\frac16 .

Note that the sum of the squared moduli is 66, as is the factor 1+1+41+1+4 that appeared in the normalisation: this is a useful check. The expectation value is ⟨L^z⟩=−ℏ⋅16+0⋅23+ℏ⋅16=0\langle\hat L_z\rangle=-\hbar\cdot\frac16+0\cdot\frac23+\hbar\cdot\frac16=0. This result could have been anticipated: the function ψ\psi is real, and the operator L^z=−iℏ ∂φ\hat L_z=-i\hbar\,\partial_\varphi has a purely imaginary expectation value for a real function, which must vanish because it must also be real.

Question 5
The measurement of L^z\hat L_z yielded ℏ\hbar. What is the state immediately after the measurement? Is this new state real?

Solution
By the projection postulate, the state is projected onto the eigenspace of L^z\hat L_z associated with ℏ\hbar, intersected here with the level n=2n=2, ℓ=1\ell=1, which is spanned by ψ211\psi_{211}. After normalisation, the state is ψ211\psi_{211}, up to a global phase:

ψ211(r)=R21(r) Y11(θ,φ)∝− rsin⁡θ eiφe−r/(2a)=−(x+iy) e−r/(2a).\psi_{211}(\mathbf r)=R_{21}(r)\,Y_{11}(\theta,\varphi)\propto-\,r\sin\theta\,e^{i\varphi}e^{-r/(2a)}=-(x+iy)\,e^{-r/(2a)}.

This is not a real function: its phase rotates with the angle φ\varphi about the zz axis, corresponding to a non-zero, well-defined component of angular momentum along zz.